As soon as I saw the “White Girl Wasted” title card at the beginning of The Social Reckoning, it immediately sighed and knew what I was in for. It also codified my opinion of “Aaron Sorkin should not direct.”
The Social Reckoning tells us all that we already know: “Surprise! The internet is a horrible place! And the social media world has evolved into a cesspool of toxicity!”
The follow-up to the 2010 The Social Network is nowhere near the orbit of the David Fincher-directed predecessor, which Sorkin also wrote. The film is fine. The Sorkin dialogue is Sorkining, but it doesn’t sing. It doesn’t crackle. His feature directorial work has been a mixed bag. The consensus has been that he should stick to screenwriting (after watching The Trial of the Chicago 7 he definitely should’ve had second thoughts of directing The Social Reckoning).
The Social Network was brooding and elegantly conniving. The Social Reckoning is sensational and felt… silly.
I find it very difficult to believe that a journalist like Jeff Horwitz (Jeremy Allen White) in the 21st century does not know how to operate a GPS system. I get that Sorkin was trying to paint him as an “old school” journalist, but to make him a luddite like this is just plum dumb. Apparently, he took liberties with the character, and the real Jeff isn’t so tech-averse. I guess it was supposed to make the character more interesting and give the movie more depth and richness. Instead, it flattened the character.
The Social Reckoning is a follow-up we didn’t necessarily ask for, but it’s good to have like a dated, dusty-ass textbook. As a movie, it would have been more relevant and exciting to have around a couple of years ago. Or maybe we didn’t need to be reminded how rotten social media can be in the first place.
The story of whistleblower Frances Haugen (Mikey Madison), the Facebook engineer who spilled all of the tea on Facebook to Jeff. The film portrays Frances — and maybe her colleague played by the underused Anna Lambe — as the only people at Facebook with a conscience.
As we have already learned in the now famous Facebook Files series in The Wall Street Journal, Facebook likes engagement and will do anything they can to bolster engagement — to the detriment of their users. When Frances discovered this, she wanted to let the world know, so she sought out Jeff. When Mark Zuckerberg (Jeremy Strong) caught word of the article, he was not a happy camper.
The film hops from 2019 to 2020 to 2021, giving us vignettes of Jeff and Frances forming a bond and eventually breaking the story and Marky Z prepping for a congressional hearing. He is being coached by Raya (Wumni Mosaku) while a close advisor, Charlie (Bill Burr), throws in critical jabs at Zucky every chance he can get.
Charlie, who is played wonderfully by Burr, was an interesting character — because he isn’t real. He blatantly represents the person in the room that should have been there. The person who tells Zuckerberg: “No.” However, this is cinema. In real life, there aren’t many people who can say “No” to a billionaire. At one point in the movie, Zuckerberg throws a tantrum and says what he says goes!
Strong’s portrayal of Zuckerberg is robotic and cartoonish, so it’s spot on and wildly entertaining and meme-able. The Succession star doesn’t disappoint, but he delivers exactly what you would expect from an actor like him.
Zuckerberg is pretty much shown as an overlord watching his subjects from a watchtower. If he had a mustache to twirl, he would be twirling it while looking at us through soulless eyes.
If Zuckerberg is the Goliath, then Jeff Horwitz is David. Frances Haugen gave Jeff the slingshot and rock to take down Zuckberg.
But did Jeff really take “down” Zuckerberg and Facebook?
Perhaps that is why this movie is so frustrating. Nothing has really changed besides an expansion of visibility and scrutiny of the problem. There has been limited impact since Facebook was exposed.
The Social Reckoning attempts to tell us “This is how bad it was and how it happened” in about two hours. Sorkin is making a movie about journalism Facebook in 2026. That description makes it sound so geriatric, but if you look beyond that, it has the potential to be something great and on the level of Spotlight or All the President’s Men, but it is so far from it.
I have an adoration for journalism movies, and it has been a long time since we’ve had a journalism movie that I’ve had the opportunity to fall in love with, and this was not it. Granted, The Social Reckoning was not solely a journalism movie, but it was a major pillar that it failed.
You feel Sorkin struggling to spin multiple plates at once to make The Social Reckoning work. Everything haphazardly culminates with the January 6th insurrection, crash landing with an anticlimactic non-resolution. We watch Zuckerberg determine whether or not it’s a good idea to take down inflammatory posts from a sitting U.S. president… and then that’s it.
With a performance that’s a cross between Stuart from Madtv and Data from Star Trek: The Next Generation, Strong, for better or worse, is the most entertaining performance in the film. Madison and White feel like they are in footnotes for the movie.
And how are you going to have an incredible actress like Wumni Mosaku and just have her instruct Jeremy Strong on how to nod his head? The same thing could be said about Betty Gilpin. She says a couple of snarky lines as Jeff’s editor and then bows out. Nonetheless, it’s lovely to see them in a movie that is the equivalent of scrolling through a Facebook timeline.
While the cast provides decent performances to satisfy the runtime of a watchable movie, there were moments of the movie that triggered me like a click-baity Facebook post. Specifically, any scene when Zuckerberg chooses algorithm over humanity.
The Social Reckoning serves as an indirect sequel to the far superior The Social Network. It’s a better movie because it had better material to work with. Sorkin attempts to combine a tech thriller, a journalism movie, and a legal drama to make a film, and he succeeds… but it’s not interesting.
You’re better off reading The Facebook Files in its entirety. It will more than likely give you more satisfaction. If anything, it’s a fantastic companion piece to this film, obviously. You’ll also be supporting journalists! Specifically, I encourage you to support local journalists. Even more specifically, I encourage you to support nonprofit independent journalists… like me.






