The character of Cliff Booth, played with an Oscar-winning wink and a smile by Brad Pitt, won our hearts in Quentin Tarantino’s Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. A handsome stuntman with Jirmack, bounce-back beautiful hair, Cliff can charm the pants off of anyone. He was also a fictional figure in a piece of revisionist history, violently murdering members of the Manson family while high on LSD and altering the events of the real-life Tate murders.
Riding the wave of Pitt’s Academy Award and the popularity of the character, one could argue that The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth grew organically out of Tarantino’s scrapped project The Movie Critic, which was supposed to star Pitt.
Set in the ’70s, after the events of Hollywood, the film shows us what life is like for a past-his-prime but still-got-it, handsome white stuntman in 1977 Hollywood.
Turns out, he has a pretty boring life, so he makes it exciting by doing daredevil stunts or being an irresistible hitman. Either way, he knows he’ll get away with murder because of that gosh darn smile, that lumberjack build, and that swagger for days. Strip all that away and what do you get? A mediocre white man the world would still celebrate.
Sure, Cliff is filled with charm, but how far can that stretch? It wears thin fairly fast. If anything, The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth is a series of vignettes, not a feature film. There’s not enough character in this human to paint on this canvas.
My Cliff Booth punch card was filled up after Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, so I thought I’d closed my chapter on him. But when Tarantino and Fincher were bringing him back, I had two questions: 1.) Why? and 2.) Will the dog be back?
The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth contains pieces of a good movie. Specifically, the tertiary characters are far more interesting than the main character: big-time insecure TV star Charlie Peters (Scott Caan); Karen Crosby (Elizabeth Debicki), the super tall agent who is always wearing white and whom Cliff has the hots for; retired football player turned movie star Roderick “Hot Rod” Harrison (Yahya Abdul-Mateen II); Cliff’s crotchety dad Gus (Peter Weller); and Eddie and Fernando Verdusco (Matt Groove and JB Tadena), Filipino gangster brothers who are here to kill Charlie’s wife, Toni (Carla Gugino), who happens to be Cliff’s former lover.
These far more interesting characters were underutilized (Timothy Olyphant was right there!), and the sidelining of actresses like Debicki and Gugino is criminal. There is one point in the film that seemingly teases the shelved Movie Critic project via an exchange between Debicki’s character and Cliff.
The talented Abdul-Mateen II was also wildly underused. At one point, his character gets beaten down by the Filipino gangsters, and it felt random, unreasonable, and unresolved. The characters felt like furniture with nothing to do.
There’s a whole lot going on in this movie. There’s also a whole lot of nothing going on. That kind of tracks for a Tarantino and Fincher film. But putting Cliff at the center of all of it is the film’s biggest failure. He’s a fun guy, but he does not make for a captivating subject for a feature film. There’s only so much you can do with a narrative about a charming stuntman who does violent stuff to “bad” people. He’s a template of a hero, which is fine, but boring.
But you know what was exciting? When the Verdusco brothers murdered that family. Yes, part of it is because I am sadistic, but also the film needed that Manson family edge from Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. That was interesting. That was Tarantino. That was Fincher. It felt dangerous. I felt uneasy. I felt unsafe. I leaned in… but it just fizzled.
And nothing felt earned.
Everything just felt handsome (in that pornstache way), messy, and annoyingly unbothered, just like the titular character.
And if you think about it, Cliff Booth is a little punk too. For a macho stuntman, he sure likes to fight and/or murder people smaller than him: Bruce Lee (they decided to double down on the disrespect toward his name in this movie), those crazy Manson folks, his ex-wife (allegedly), and now the Verdusco brothers. So by my count, Mr. Booth has an affinity for harming Asian people, women, and progressive hippies. (For the record, I don’t condone the behavior of murderous radical cultists. Nor do I condone the murdering or beating of Asian folks.)
As a Filipino, I would be remiss not to say that I appreciate that Matt Groove and JB Tadena put an unapologetic Pinoy stamp on this motherfucker, subverting expectations of what a Filipino character should be. But having Cliff Booth wear a traditional barong tagalog while murdering two Filipinos was a choice.
At first, I found it quite offensive, because how dare this colonizer wear our traditional garb to violently maim my people. Then I realized it was quite poetic, considering the storied, complex history the Filipino people share with America (which is folded into the narrative). As someone wise pointed out to me, it speaks a lot to how “some Filipinos worship white culture to our detriment.”
The character of Cliff Booth is presented like Tarantino’s favorite action figure, complete with signature sunglasses and a myriad of accessories (the lovable pit bull Brandy not included). Like any action figure, he’s fun out of the package, but the novelty of his charm wears off the more you play with him. Even his past as an adult XXX star was barely interesting. (Why didn’t they make that the central focus of the movie? Sure, that would have given it Boogie Nights energy, but at least the “sex sells” angle would have been more interesting to watch than whatever this was.)
There are tons of misses in The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth. Those neck-deep in the entertainment industry will feel the rumored production hiccups and woes radiate off the screen, while audiences will enjoy the surface-level, streaming-friendly “fun” of the movie. It’s perfect for Netflix, but an unworthy follow-up to its superior predecessor.






